Nov 17 2009
Week 12 Heisman Island: Clausen goes down with the ship

For the second straight week, we lost a big-name quarterback out here at Heisman Island. Last week, it was Tim Tebow’s floundering campaign that was finally brought to an unequivocal close and put out to sea. This week, we bid farewell to Jimmy Clausen as the sinking ship known as Notre Dame pulls him under the great blue sea.
Meanwhile, the list of remaining hopefuls is cut from ten to eight as we begin the process of winnowing it down to a final five. Also, Stanford’s previously ignored star tailback, Toby Gerhart, makes a last-minute debut after his team pulled off yet another shocking upset and suddenly finds itself with legitimate top 25 relevancy.
8. Case Keenum (Houston)
Commentary: Despite playing through what was easily the worst game of his season, Keenum still managed to put up another eye-popping stat line. However, it’s tough to take a Heisman candidate seriously when his team loses to UCF—and he throws a pivotal interception midway through the fourth quarter that leads to a touchdown for the opposition. Right now, Houston is clinging to one of the last few spots in the top 25 so, great numbers aside, Keenum can ill afford another Houston loss.
Previous Rank: 3
Highest Rank: 3
Last Week Stats: 377 passing yards, 3 touchdowns, 1 interception, 58.9 pct., 129.6 rating; 8 rushing yards, 0 touchdowns.
Season Stats: 4155 passing yards, 31 touchdowns, 6 interceptions, 69.5 pct., 155.4 rating; 103 rushing yards, 3 touchdowns.
7. Toby Gerhart (Stanford)
Commentary: After beating the top two teams in the Pac-10 back-to-back, Stanford has certainly merited a top 25 ranking, which is great news for Gerhart’s candidacy. The star tailback currently sits third in the nation in rushing yards and second in rushing touchdowns. Much like Clemson’s C.J. Spiller, the only thing holding Gerhart back is his team’s three losses.
Previous Rank: Unranked
Highest Rank: 7
Last Week Stats: 178 rushing yards, 3 touchdowns, 6.1 YPC; 9 receiving yards, 0 touchdowns.
Season Stats: 1395 rushing yards, 19 touchdowns, 5.3 YPC; 87 receiving yards, 0 touchdowns.
6. Kellen Moore (Boise State)
Commentary: Going into the season, no one would have guessed that the last quarterback standing with any kind of real Heisman legitimacy would play for little Boise State. Moore may not have Keenum’s passing yardage, but he does have more touchdowns, fewer interceptions, a better passer rating, and an undefeated football squad. If anyone in the top five slips up in the coming weeks, you can bet that Moore will be primed to move on up in the rankings.
Previous Rank: 8
Highest Rank: 6
Last Week Stats: 299 passing yards, 5 touchdowns, 0 interceptions, 68.8 pct., 198.8 rating; 2 rushing yards, 0 touchdowns.
Season Stats: 2558 passing yards, 32 touchdowns, 3 interceptions, 67.4 pct., 171.9 rating; -11 rushing yards, 1 touchdown.
5. LaMichael James (Oregon)
Commentary: Although James doesn’t appear to be getting much love from the big-name pundits out there, I think his level of play has certainly merited inclusion in the discussion of the Heisman top five. Not only is he the single biggest reason for Oregon’s success this year, but he’s also second in the nation in yards-per-carry average among backs with a minimum of 150 carries. Heisman voters, don’t penalize James just because you didn’t know who he was at the start of the season. If LeGarrette Blount hadn’t thrown a punch after the opener and instead had gone on to have this kind of season, don’t you think he’d be getting serious Heisman consideration at this point?
Previous Rank: 5
Highest Rank: 3
Last Week Stats: 150 rushing yards, 3 touchdowns, 6.8 YPC; 0 receiving yards, 0 touchdowns.
Season Stats: 1193 rushing yards, 11 touchdown, 7.0 YPC; 128 receiving yards, 0 touchdowns.
4. Jordan Shipley (Texas)
Commentary: So, maybe Texas didn’t really need wide receivers in their blowout of overmatched Baylor, but Shipley still came up with two more receiving scores to add to his stat line. I realize that it’s become increasingly difficult for wideouts to receive Heisman invitations, but Shipley is as good as they come and he’s been the top playmaker for the undefeated ‘Horns all season long.
Previous Rank: 4
Highest Rank: 3
Last Week Stats: 46 receiving yards, 2 touchdowns; 9.3 PR AVG, 0 touchdowns.
Season Stats: 1096 receiving yards, 8 touchdowns; 13.8 PR AVG, 2 touchdowns.
3. C.J. Spiller (Clemson)
Commentary: Rushing touchdowns? Check. Receiving touchdowns? Check. Punt return touchdown? Check. Kickoff return touchdowns? Check. Passing touchdown? Check! The Clemson sensation has now scored in every imaginable way on offense this season. What’s next? Put him in at corner so he can get a pick-six? The guy is simply amazing and a true joy to watch.
Previous Rank: 6
Highest Rank: 3
Last Week Stats: 97 rushing yards, 1 touchdown, 5.4 YPC, ; 48 receiving yards, 1 touchdown; 13.0 KR AVG, 0 touchdowns; 17 passing yards, 1 touchdown.
Season Stats: 836 rushing yards, 6 touchdowns, 5.5 YPC, ; 382 receiving yards, 4 touchdowns; 27.0 PR AVG, 1 touchdown; 34.3 KR AVG, 3 touchdowns; 17 passing yards, 1 touchdown.
2. Dion Lewis (Pittsburgh)
Commentary: Lewis’ Heisman campaign reminds me a lot of LaMichael James’ in that it seems to be whispered in hushed tones in close circles—that is, if it’s even spoken of at all. It’s like the collegiate version of the old “elephant in the room” cliche. You know it’s there, but no one ever really talks about it. Well, I’m here to tell you that Lewis deserves better. The season he’s put together in his first year at Pitt deserves to be broadcast nationally all across the airwaves. So, rise up Panther fans! Let’s hear some Heisman noise for this frosh tailback who has single-handedly carried you into the top ten, when a lot of preseason pundits didn’t even envision your squad cracking the top 30.
Previous Rank: 2
Highest Rank: 2
Last Week Stats: 152 rushing yards, 1 touchdown, 7.2 YPC; 8 receiving yards, 0 touchdowns.
Season Stats: 1291 rushing yards, 13 touchdown, 5.8 YPC; 142 receiving yards, 1 touchdown.
1. Mark Ingram (Alabama)
Commentary: The Heisman race looks to be Ingram’s to lose. And, no, don’t you dare even mention a certain Gators quarterback. I don’t care if Florida wins the SEC and plays Texas in the national championship. The only player deserving of a Heisman invitation on those two squads would be the aforementioned Shipley. Anyway, in the meantime, with Alabama taking on hapless Chattanooga this weekend, look for Ingram to put up some impressive numbers as he continues to build on his lead.
Previous Rank: 1
Highest Rank: 1
Last Week Stats: 149 rushing yards, 2 touchdowns, 7.8 YPC; 9 receiving yards, 0 touchdowns.
Season Stats: 1297 rushing yards, 10 touchdowns, 6.7 YPC; 225 receiving yards, 3 touchdowns.






















